I agree and disagree, I remember we (you) brought it back several times, I like the idea because in a sense I feel some of the "lurkers" will be more apt to post in that to get their feet wet here rather then start a new thread or jump in on a discussion. On the other side I see this as robbing the forum of vital posts that keep things rolling. So it may be something you would like to do as a trial and kinda monitor post counts etc to see if we show an increase or decrease that's the main focus here.
Rules should be set forth so that body building, aas etc discussions should strictly be left in the designated forums, so that it does not take away from that as well.