Tony vs Gunter

[mb97]

Lightsout and I got to talking about this in another thread so I thought i would start a new one. Gunther vs Tony, not condition because it changed from show to show but shape and size. Who would you pick?

 

[mb97]

back

 

[mb97]

I pick Tony.

 

[big in vegas]

I've gotta go with Tony as well, he's always had a nice size and shape in my opinion

 

[Boomer]

What's wrong with Tony's right pec?

 

[The Dude]

What's wrong with Tony's right pec?

He ruptured it several years ago as I did. When it ruptures the muscle pulls away from the tendon. It is irrepairable. It never looks the same or acts the same.

 

[Boomer]

He ruptured it several years ago as I did. When it ruptures the muscle pulls away from the tendon. It is irrepairable. It never looks the same or acts the same.

Would he get marked down for that on stage?

 

[Chris250]

Would he get marked down for that on stage?

well its possiable...like the other night..Toney and Hide was fighting for 2nd and 3rd..and Hide got the lead and took 2nd....Toney has 60 + lbs on Hide, but for some reason Hide got the lead with his insane conditioning. Toney was close on conditioning, and much fuller looking. But Hide really knows how to get everything out of his body and make it look really good...

 

[The Dude]

well its possiable...like the other night..Toney and Hide was fighting for 2nd and 3rd..and Hide got the lead and took 2nd....Toney has 60 + lbs on Hide, but for some reason Hide got the lead with his insane conditioning. Toney was close on conditioning, and much fuller looking. But Hide really knows how to get everything out of his body and make it look really good...

Toney hides that pec VERY well. If you watch him pose and no that the pec is damaged you will see that he never gives you the opportunity to look at it and notice or compare it.

 

[Mrbigz]

I like Gunter, over toney. Gunter out muscles him every where, his waist may be a little thicker but his body over all looks better. IMO toney's lower body just doesnt match up